Cooperative and Condominium

July 10, 2025

Social Media Influencer Fails to Stick the Landing: New York Cooperative Board Rejection

News outlets have reported that former gymnast Livvy Dunne’s application to purchase a NYC apartment once owned by Yankees legend Babe Ruth was rejected by the cooperative board. Although the news was disappointing to the young social media influencer, such a decision was mostly likely a prudent one and not entirely unexpected. This post will provide a legal analysis of cooperative board declinations.

We have previously written about the cooperative board approval process. So long as the purchaser was not rejected due to illegal discriminatory reasons, a rejection is considered to be legally tenable. Further, the reasons for the declination need not be disclosed. Applicants are legally protected from discrimination if the reason that they are rejected is due to characteristics such as their race, religion, sexual orientation and the like.

Dunne’s proposed purchase was purportedly an all cash purchase, with no bank loan. Her board application would have included proof of funds and other financial details. Ironically enough, some boards prefer to approve a purchaser who is using a bank loan for the purchase, since the lender has professionally evaluated the creditworthiness of the proposed purchaser. Dunne’s livelihood as a social media influencer may have been seen as without substance and fleeting by the board. Should she “go out of style”, her income may become depleted and her ability to maintain financial obligations to the building may not be met in the future.

June 5, 2025

Homeowners’ Associations in New York – The Basics and Non-Payment of Dues

By Weiss & Weiss

Although they are not as prevalent in New York State as they are in other states, Homeowners’ Associations still exist here, and may raise significant legal issues for those who are members, as well as for the Association itself.

The main reason that there are not as many Homeowners’ Associations in New York is probably because of the large number of condominiums and cooperative units in our state, especially in the New York City area. Condos and coops are legal associations which connect owners of various units, usually apartments. In a cooperative, each unit owner purchases shares in the cooperative corporation, rather than actual real estate. The coop unit owner also acquires a proprietary lease allowing occupancy of a particular apartment. A condominium operates similarly, but owners in a condominium purchase the actual real estate, rather than shares, and own their individual units, as well as a portion of the common areas.

A Homeowners’ Association operates similarly, but has differences from a condo or coop. Each homeowner owns his individual real estate, which can be an apartment or, more commonly, a house. Membership in an Association is generally mandated by the Declaration filed for the development in question and referenced in the deed to the property. The Association is a separate legal entity, and is authorized by its by-laws to collect dues. These dues are then used by the Association to pay common charges associated with the properties, such as water and sewer charges and maintenances charges such as landscaping and gardening, pool maintenance, and similar expenses associated with the group of properties which constitute membership in the Association.

January 31, 2025

Foreclosure Defense – Playing the Numbers Game

By Weiss & Weiss

When our firm is retained by a new client whose property is in danger of being foreclosed, one of the first issues that needs to be determined relates to the equity in the property. Equity can be defined as the net value of the property, once all liabilities are calculated. It is an important component of deciding the correct game plan for defending any potential foreclosure action.

The first step towards calculating the equity in a property is to obtain an estimate of the current market value of the property. Although there are online service such as Zillow which may give an estimate of a home’s current value, these “zestimates” are approximate and may not reflect the current physical condition of the property. In order to obtain the most accurate value, we recommend hiring a professional appraiser. The appraiser is an independent licensed professional who will thoroughly examine both the interior and exterior of the house, and also compare it to other similar properties on the market in the area where the property is located. Once they have completed their inspection, they will provide a written report which gives a current market value for the specific property.

The second step is determining the current debt on the property. Payoff letters can be requested from the current mortgage holder. Keep in mind that there may be more than one mortgage on the property, requiring obtaining multiple payoff letters. The payoff letter will show the amount needed to pay off the outstanding mortgage. Depending upon how advanced the mortgage foreclosure process has proceeded, there may be additional charges added by the lender, such as property taxes advanced by the lender, as well as costs and attorneys’ fees for any foreclosure actions.

January 13, 2025

Foreclosure Protections in New York – When do They Apply?

By Weiss & Weiss

As long-time readers of this blog may be aware, New York State has significant protections in place for defendants in foreclosure actions. These legal requirements are meant to ensure that a homeowner is allowed an opportunity to defend his case, or at least be aware of a pending and existing foreclosure matter, and allow him an opportunity to enlist experienced legal counsel in order to protect his interest in his property.

With the economy in recession, and home interest rates having significantly risen due to efforts to forestall inflation, many borrowers now find themselves at risk of foreclosure. The first legal protection in place is that if the home loan is in default, the lender must give a written notice of one hundred and twenty (120) days prior to commencing a foreclosure action. Other legal notices may also be required to be sent by the lender (or their attorneys) prior to a lawsuit being filed.

Once a lawsuit commences and an Answer is filed, the Court will then schedule a foreclosure settlement conference. Under New York law, the matter cannot proceed further until all parties meet in a settlement conference to discuss the case and attempt, in good faith, to negotiate a resolution. Depending upon the results of the settlement conference, the Court may schedule additional conferences, as the lender may require submission of financial documents from the borrower so that a loan modification can be negotiated and approved. If a loan modification is made, the borrower must show that he is complying with its terms by making regular payments before the foreclosure case can be dismissed.

October 24, 2024

Eviction Action or Ejectment Action?

By Weiss & Weiss

Our firm is involved in many situations in which one party seeks to remove another party from property, such as a house, cooperative, or condominium unit. However, the situation underlying the attempted removal will often determine the correct legal method for effectuating said removal.

The two main legal remedies are an eviction action and an ejectment action. Keep in mind that there may be situations in which an experienced attorney needs to use his legal judgment to determine which type of action to bring. First, we will cover an eviction action.

Eviction actions are generally used in ordinary landlord-tenant matters. In most cases, there is a tenant who is renting property from the property owner, who is the landlord. There usually is a written lease, but not in all situations. There are generally two types of eviction actions. The first is a non-payment, in which the tenant has failed to pay her rent. The second is a holdover, in which the tenant’s lease has expired, or a situation in which the tenant never had a lease and has a month-to-month tenancy.

September 24, 2024

Legal Issues Relating to the Sale of Inherited Property

By Weiss & Weiss

Our firm has often been consulted by clients who inherited a house from their parents, and wish to sell the property, as they may have moved out-of-state, and the property became vacant after the passing of the last parent.

Usually, this is a straightforward transaction, which often requires legal assistance in acquiring legal authority to sell the property as part of an estate. This involves experienced counsel filing for letters testamentary (if there is a will) or letters of administration (if there is no will). Once the Surrogate’s Court issues the proper legal document, then the sale can proceed.

However, there is often another issue, which may become known to the surviving children only after their parents’ death. It is possible that the parents borrowed against the property, even after the original mortgage that they took out to purchase the premises was paid off. Often a reverse mortgage is taken out by the elderly parents, in order to raise funds to continue to live in the house. Generally, such mortgages are only available to homeowners over the age of 62. Once the loan funds are disbursed, there are no monthly payments. The full amount of the loan would then be due after the death of the last borrower.

September 18, 2024

Considerations When Making a Will as to Potential Property Sharing by Heirs

By Weiss & Weiss

Clients consulting our firm with respect to will drafting often ask how to leave a house or cooperative apartment to potential heirs when there may be more than one surviving child. Perhaps a person owns a house and wants to leave it to all three of her children in her Will. Concerns arise when one of the children has been living in the house all of his life or only one of the children frequently enjoys the use of the house as a vacation home. In either case, the remaining children have no use for the property. The well-intentioned parent may be inadvertently causing a family dispute after her death. If the child who wants the property does not have the financial ability to buy out his siblings, by mortgage financing or otherwise, the remaining siblings may have no choice except for engaging an experienced attorney to commence a partition action.

The person making the Will also needs to determine whether she wishes for her children to inherit in equal portions. For example, if the house is of particular interest to one child and there are other assets available to be distributed to the other children, the parent may decide to leave the other assets to the other children, so that each child receives substantially similar disbursements.

We have reviewed documents prepared by others providing that a person can continue to reside in the house until a particular triggering event such as vacating the house or death, after such event those who will inherit the property can have full access and sell it if they wish. Such a document may provide that the occupant pay the property expenses while occupying. This arrangement is not one that we recommend because it delays the delivery of the asset to the intended owner(s) and the occupant may not meet property upkeep demands, which provisions are difficult to enforce.

October 6, 2022

Couple or Throuple? Succession Rights in New York Rental Units

By Weiss & Weiss

Our firm often fields inquiries from clients regarding successor rights in New York residential rental apartments. First, experienced counsel should determine whether the premises are subject to rent regulation. Rent regulation in New York State applies to many, but not all, residential units. It is more prevalent in New York City than in its surrounding suburbs. However, it does also cover some rental units in Westchester and Nassau Counties.

Assuming that rent regulation does apply to the premises, then the current occupants may be allowed successor rights once the original party on the lease either passes away or vacates the premises. For example, let’s assume Grandma rents an apartment subject to rent regulation, and only her name is on the original lease. As Grandma ages, some of her grandchildren move in to take care of her, and eventually become permanent occupants of the premises. Even though they are not listed as tenants on the original lease, these individuals, as family members occupying the premises, may be entitled to a successor lease once Grandma passes away or moves out of state.

A recent New York City Court case raises new possibilities regarding the legal definition of “family members” as they apply to more modern, non-traditional relationships. The case of West 49^th Street, LLC v. O’Neill involved a New York City apartment which was occupied by three unmarried individuals, only one of whom was on the rent-stabilized lease. After the death of the named tenant, one of the other individuals claimed that he was a non-traditional family member, despite the fact that the third individual, and not him, was the “life partner” of the deceased for over twenty-five years.

April 11, 2022

Cold Feet- Do I have to Close?

By Weiss & Weiss

We have encountered parties to real estate transactions who get “cold feet” between the time of contract signing and closing. These persons may seek to break the legally binding contract that they have signed and cancel the deal. This post will address when failing to perform a real estate contract may be permitted and the risks involved should the contract not be able to be cancelled.

First, this issue will be examined from the perspective of the buyer. Real estate contracts typically contain conditions, such as the property will appraise for at least the contract price, that the buyer will obtain a mortgage commitment, board approval will be issued if the purchase involves a cooperative apartment and there will not be an insurmountable title issue. If any of these conditions are not met and the buyer’s attorney notifies the seller’s attorney within the timeframe required by the contract, the contract can be legally cancelled and the downpayment will be refunded to the buyer.

At times, a buyer attempts to use issues that should have been addressed during the pre-contract due diligence period to cancel the contract. Most contracts state that the buyer has conducted all due diligence and inspections of the property before the contract is signed. The buyer’s concerns about such issues as property conditions, the amount of real estate taxes, or monthly carrying costs of a cooperative or condominium unit must be raised before the contract is signed and are not causes to unravel the contract. A buyer cannot cancel the contract merely because he no longer wants the property or thinks he cannot afford it.

December 1, 2021

Pre-Litigation Settlements of Partition Matters

By Weiss & Weiss

Our firm receives many inquiries from co-owners of properties. As longtime readers of this blog are aware, a partition action can be brought in the appropriate Court when co-owners cannot agree on the disposition of real property. Such an action would demand that the Court appoint a Referee to determine the respective shares of the co-owners, and, if necessary, actually sell the property.

However, there are often situations in which the parties may agree to the disposition of the property without resorting to actual litigation. In this pre-litigation period, the parties, through their attorneys, may negotiate a resolution in which either one party can buy the other’s share of the property, or agree to jointly sell the property and share the proceeds. In such a situation, experienced counsel should prepare a written agreement, to ensure compliance with the parties’ understanding.

What provisions should be included in such an agreement? The agreement should first state that the parties are co-owners of the property, and the exact amount of their percentage shares of ownership. Next, there should be terms for the disposition of the property. For example, two brothers inherit a house from their parents, and agree to sell the property and share the proceeds equally. The agreement should state that the parties will cooperate in hiring a licensed real estate broker to market and sell the property. The agreement may even include more details, such as the name of the real estate broker, and the initial listing price for the property.